Home > News & Events > Department of Labor: Independent Contractor vs. Employee
 

Photo

This Legal Update frequently warns employers of the risk of improperly classifying workers as independent contractors.

Photo

 

Practice Areas



legal updates

May 2009

U.S. Department of Labor Update



Department of Labor

Pursues Employer of Misclassified

Independent Contractors


By Christopher W. Olmsted

This Legal Update frequently warns employers of the risk of improperly classifying workers as independent contractors. Employers are often too cavalier about concluding that they have satisfied the myriad of independent contractor status criteria, and rest with the false sense of security provided by independent contractor agreements. Government agencies can and frequently do challenge independent contractor status, written agreements notwithstanding.

DOL Scrutinizes Independent Contractor Status


The U.S. Department of Labor is one of several government agencies that may take issue with improper classification of workers. Primarily, the DOL is concerned with the failure to pay such workers minimum wage and overtime. A properly classified independent contractor is not subject to these wage and hour laws. But where a company mistakenly classifies a worker as independent when he ought to be classified as an employee, a worker’s excess hours may lead to minimum wage and overtime liability.

California Employer Hit Hard


A Southern California cleaning service and its owners have found themselves in such a predicament. According to a recent DOL press release, the investigation by the Labor Department's Wage and Hour Division leading to the 2007 order determined that the Gardena, California-based Southern California Maid Services and Carpet Cleaning had improperly classified 385 employees as independent contractors and failed to pay them at least minimum wage and overtime as required under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). In a court order signed Aug. 21, 2007, a federal judge ordered the company and its owners to pay the workers $3.5 million in back wages plus $1,058,973 in liquidated damages.

Pursuant to the court’s April 2009 order, the cleaning company must also now pay $227,791 in post-judgment interest plus $2,000 per day in fines for contempt of court. The owners must also each pay fines of $200 per day.

"The Department of Labor will not hesitate to take action to ensure workers receive the compensation they have worked hard for and earned," blandly observed Hilda L. Solis, the newly appointed Obama administration Secretary of Labor.

According to the DOL press release, the Wage and Hour Division learned of the employer's practices through its participation in the Employment Education and Outreach (EMPLEO) partnership. EMPLEO is an alliance of organizations and government agencies that assist Spanish-speaking workers and employers with work-related concerns.

To avoid similar misfortune, before hiring independent contractors, companies should carefully evaluate state and federal independent contractor criteria, and seek legal advice in the face of any uncertainty.

Further Resources
Need help determining independent contractor status? Request our complimentary independent contractor guideline.

More Legal Update articles.
Download entire May 2009 Legal Update in PDF format.


This article is intended as a brief overview of the law and are not intended to substitute as legal advice. Any questions or concerns regarding any statute or case law should be addressed to a licensed attorney. Copyright © 2009 by Barker Olmsted & Barnier, APLC. San Diego, California. All rights reserved.




Sign up for the monthly Barker Olmsted & Barnier newsletter:

Name:  
Company Name :  
Job Title:  
E-mail: